Is Cali Ray Come Hell or High Water Mascara worth it?

Mostly yes. 3 of the 4 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 76%.

What is Cali Ray Come Hell or High Water Mascara's Guru Score?

Cali Ray Come Hell or High Water Mascara holds a Guru Score of 76%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 4 expert reviewers we have collected. At least one expert has named it a Top Pick in its category.

Cali Ray

Cali Ray Come Hell or High Water Mascara.

Save to Pinterest

Eye Makeup

About this product

A tubing mascara that wraps each lash in a removable tube of color, designed for long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking.

Guru Score

76%

Yay

Early verdict · Few reviews so far

What the gurus are saying

This tubing mascara earns consistent praise for staying put through sweat and tears without smudging, flaking, or chipping, and for removing cleanly without leaving residue. Multiple experts highlight the soft, fluffy lash effect and the fact that it works with just one coat, though one reviewer noted the wand comes overly saturated with product, requiring some cleanup before application. For anyone who sweats, cries, or needs their mascara to hold all day, this is a trusted pick.

Synthesized from 4 expert reviews · most recent take April 2026

What they liked

Doesn't smudge, chip or flake, even when sweating
Removes easily without leaving black specks
Doesn't dry out in the tube

What they flagged

Wand comes out overloaded with product
Some transfer and cleanup needed on application

Type

Eye MakeupLiquid

Where to buy

Sephora → Amazon → Google →

Opens a store search. We may earn from these links.

Scan it in the shopFree iPhone app. Scores in the aisle.

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

AliceintheRabbitHole

59k subs

✓Yay

"The Cali Ray mascara is a tubing mascara and it's incredible. That's still going to be my pick."

Top Pick: tubing mascara

Beyond50Skin

32k subs

✓Nay

"The Clio Ray Come Hell or High Water, as far as application got a 2 out of five it did have some transfer required a little bit of cleanup and the look was also a 2 out of five a little bit of clumping but a little bit longer than perhaps the Tarte but not what I expect of a tubing mascara. As far as smudge, oh my gosh there was so much fallout and smudge from this it got a 1 out of five I would not recommend this as a smudge proof mascara at all."

Allie Glines

829k subs

✓Yay

"For mascara, I love this one from Cali Ray. I'm wearing it today. It's going to give you really soft, subtle, fluffy lashes. It's actually a tubing mascara and it has a little brush wand. [...] It's one of the best tubing mascaras. This is great for if you are running around chasing a toddler, you're sweating. Like, it's not going to smudge or flake, which is so important to me. And it's just really subtle. It's really soft and gentle looking on the eyes."

Sponsored

All 8 takes from Allie Glines

What’s Worth It from the Sephora Sale + My Cart 👀

"This is actually a tubing mascara from Cali Ray. This was a staple for me the last couple of months. Anytime that I know I'm going to be crying this is what I like to wear. I do a light layer or you can build it up but it's something that just really does not budge. It's so nice. I absolutely love this."

My No-Overwhelm Guide to the Sephora Sale (What’s Actually Worth It) ✨

The PERFECT Summer Makeup (Easy for Everyday)

"Summertime means you gotta have a pretty heavy duty mascara and for me it's this one from Cali Ray. I love it so much. It's a tubing mascara, it's also a clean formula, it doesn't go anywhere. This is like my go to if I know I'm going to be sweating. This is what I reach for."

10 Beauty Products I'm Using ALL SUMMER LONG 😍

"When the weather heats up, it's really important to pick a mascara that's going to hold up through the humidity, the heat, the water, whatever. So for me personally, that's when I go into my tubing mascaras. My two favorites are the Clio one and then also the one from Thrive Cosmetics."

The Trendy "Latte" Makeup.. Let's try it!

"I'm gonna do my Cali Ray mascara"

What's ACTUALLY in Lisa J's Makeup Bag?!

"My more everyday is this Clio Ray one, it's a tubing mascara and it's just kind of more of a thin formula so it just like, it gives that fanned out more fluffy lash, not too over the top. You can build it up if you want to."

This NEW Makeup is INSANE 🤯

"I'm gonna use my Cali Ray one today. I almost put this in my brows, oh my word that would have been insane. I'm gonna put this on my lashes. Hallelujah I didn't do that."

My Stress-Free Sephora Savings Guide! 🤗🛍️

"These two are my favorites at Sephora. I feel like I always talk about them because they're just so good and nothing has really topped them for me from Sephora."

HotandFlashy

1.23M subs

✓Yay

"This is like the perfect mascara for me. It makes my lashes look long and silky. It's easy to apply and it's also easy to remove. This is a tubing mascara and so it never has clumps. This does go on a little bit wet but once it dries it is in place. If you have leaky eyes every time you go out in the cold and you always have that little mascara dribble down there, then this is going to be the mascara for you to replace whatever you're using because this one stays in place."

Sponsored

All 12 takes from HotandFlashy

SPRING Sephora SALE! Top Picks for Mature Skin!

"Now when it comes out it's just so coated with so much mascara I end up wiping it back on the package because I don't want to waste it all, but it's just so much and it's always like globbed on the end and it's making a big mess and I try to put it on and it's like too much goes on at once. I don't know if it's just this one that I bought, maybe the gasket isn't working or if they changed the packaging, but this is the most recent one that I got."

Holiday Party Makeup with Easy Long-Wear Red Lip! Tips & Tricks for Mature Women!

"I love this one because it stays on until you take it off. Wipe off the excess on the edge of the tube because it is a little bit wet when you're putting it on at first. It can be a little clumpy if you just leave everything on the brush, but if you brush it off a little bit then you can get the perfect lashes. Start way down at the base and give it a little wiggle and then pull through. This mascara gives my lashes length, gives them volume, no clumps. Big lashes."

Haircare, Body Skincare, Makeup Empties | Joining the Gray Hair Movement?

"This is my current Holy Grail mascara I absolutely love this, I just love it so much. It's a tubing mascara but it removes really really easily with my double cleanse routine and it doesn't leave little black specks all over my face. It seems to dissolve a lot better than most tubing mascaras do. I love how it goes on, I love how it makes my lashes look. It makes them hold a curl, it makes them look twice as long, twice as much volume, and it does it with one coat."

How to Pack 10 Days of Outfits (+ Skincare, Makeup, Haircare) in ONE Carry-On Suitcase!

"I love this for travel because it's waterproof makeup that's considered liquid is your mascara so I have my Cali Ray love that"

Quick & Easy Summer Makeup + NEW Awesome Sunscreen!

"The mascara I'm using today is also from Cali Ray, it's their Come Hell or High Water Mascara. This is my current Holy Grail especially for the summer because it's a tubing mascara and so even if it's hot or if I'm sweaty this doesn't budge, it doesn't flake, it doesn't smear, it stays in place so beautifully. I love it so much and then it's really easy to remove at night as well."

Sephora Holiday SALE! What to Buy | My Top Picks!

"This is a tubing mascara and it is awesome. I love tubing mascaras because they stay put way better than traditional mascaras. I have [...] one eye that's a little bit leaky [...] and if I don't have on this tubing mascara I end up with a little mascara dribble down here by the end of the day, and this eliminates that problem completely because once you put this on it is on and it doesn't come off until you take it off."

Trash or Treasure? Reviewing Products I've Used Up! Makeup, Skincare, Beauty

BEST Makeup of 2023! Drugstore + High End | Mature Beauty!

"I put this one on this morning when I did this tutorial and then I took my dogs for a walk outside it was about 38° out today so pretty cold and my eyes were watering and look at that no running no smudging. [...] This doesn't come off until you take it off but once you go to take it off it's really easy to remove. I love how it makes my lashes look it gives me volume and length and curl."

BEST Makeup of 2022 | Drugstore + Department Store | Over 50!

"I have never met a tubing mascara that I liked before. I like how they look and I like how they work, but I hate it when I remove them because instead of dissolving they break up into little bits and the little bits always cling to my skin. [...] But this is the first tubing mascara that I've met that actually rinses away cleanly and doesn't leave little polka dots all over my face. It's really easy to remove, which is very important with mascara, but it's also super beautiful on the eyelashes."

Sephora Spring Sale 2023! My Top Picks & What's In My Cart!

"I end up with flakes all over, raccoon eyes after three or four hours. [...] I just keep coming back to this and being like I'm sorry, I will never leave you again. [...] This is my new holy grail. I love it. It's a tubing mascara so it goes on and it doesn't come off until you take it off. It doesn't flake, it doesn't smudge, it doesn't budge. It's waterproof. If you're swimming or crying it will stay where you put it."

Talkin' Trash! Love IT or Leave IT Skincare, Haircare, & Makeup!

"This is my new Holy Grail. [...] This is a tubing mascara. I love this one so much. It gives my lashes so much length, so much volume. It's so easy to take off, so easy to put on, stays put all day. Absolutely love it. Definitely if you have like leaky eyes that tend to make your mascara dribble, then give this one a try—that should be able to solve that."

Faves + Fails! BEST & WORST of the Month! Sept 2022

"The Cali Ray Come Hell or High Water Mascara has become my favorite mascara. This is such a good formula. With just one coat on one side [...] and no coats on the other side, [...] it's just amazing how it lengthens and gives volume and actually curls my lashes. I love this; I've never seen anything that with one coat made my lashes so big and so long, but this is amazing."