ColourPop Eyeliner: a Guru Score of 73% from 4 skincare experts

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

~Yay

"I'm going to go in with a Colourpop gel pencil because these always have... I can always guarantee if I'm doing a really bright eye look, one of the Colourpop gel pencils is going to match the look. This one's like slightly metallic."

Kelly Driscoll

90k subs

~Yay

"I'm going to use the ColourPop cream gel liner. The color is Honey Dude. And I'm going to put that on the lower waterline. And this is the secret to making your eyes look bigger is to do the darker underneath and then the lighter on the inside of the lid. It really makes your eyes nice and big."

All 2 takes from Kelly Driscoll

GRWM YouTube Creator Collective 2025 | Skincare, Hair, Makeup + Outfit!

"I'm going to use the ColourPop cream gel liner. The color is Honey Dude. And I'm going to put that on the lower waterline. And this is the secret to making your eyes look bigger is to do the darker underneath and then the lighter on the inside of the lid. It really makes your eyes nice and big."

Filming Routine | Do Skincare, Hair and Makeup With Me!

"I use the ColourPop cream gel eyeliner, this is like a nude or a flesh colored gel eyeliner, and I use this to line the waterline of my lower eyelid. This is something I learned from watching Kramas, and it really opens up the eye in a very natural, hard-to-detect way. See how it just makes my eye look more open and a little bit wider."

Alexandra Anele

1.44M subs

~Yay

"For lids I'm using this ColourPop eyeliner, [...] gorgeous red, because I knew everything else I was using was going to be very gray toned, [...] so I wanted to include a pop of color that was really going to make my eyes pop. That's why I went in with that kind of burgundy red."

All 2 takes from Alexandra Anele

Your New Favorite Goth Makeup Tutorial

"For lids I'm using this ColourPop eyeliner, [...] gorgeous red, because I knew everything else I was using was going to be very gray toned, [...] so I wanted to include a pop of color that was really going to make my eyes pop. That's why I went in with that kind of burgundy red."

How to make Dark Brown Eyes POP

"Their eyeliners are some of my absolute favorites. They have every single color. The formula is so creamy and nice. I find it doesn't irritate my eyes at all. [...] The payoff of this is so nice. I'll just take that eyeliner and angle it a little bit so that I'm going just over that line so there's no gaps when I go in with whatever eyeshadow, and it just makes the waterline color even more impactful."

Beyond50Skin

32k subs

~Nay

"The ColourPop eyeliner didn't work for me. It's too stiff and it just kind of pulls and tugs, and it's very uncomfortable on my waterline. I'm not going to get rid of it by any means, but it isn't one that I'm going to reach for again and again, and I'm definitely not going to be repurchasing it. It's just a little on the stiff side. It's creamy, but I like it a little bit more shimmery, and this is definitely more on the matte side."

What the evidence says.

Independent of what the gurus think, this is what the published research supports about the main active ingredients here.

Frequently asked.

What is ColourPop Eyeliner?

A colored eyeliner pencil from Colourpop designed to add vibrant color definition to the eye area.

Is ColourPop Eyeliner worth it?

The gurus mostly approve it, but with enough reservations to keep it in the middle at a Guru Score of 73%.

What is ColourPop Eyeliner's Guru Score?

ColourPop Eyeliner holds a Guru Score of 73%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 4 expert reviewers we have collected.