An eyeshadow palette from Melt Cosmetics featuring poison-themed shade names and a range of colors.
Guru Score
The Guru Score: every expert's verdict on a product, in one simple number.
Under the score you'll see how many experts weighed in, or "Early verdict" while only a few have. Paid takes count for half in the score.
Guru Certified means at least 6 experts, a score of 85% or more, and almost no Nays.
How we score →Yay
Early verdict · Few reviews so farWhat the gurus are saying
These eyeshadows deliver impressive color payoff with highly pigmented formulas that earn praise. The greens and purples particularly stand out, and the gurus appreciated both the rich pigmentation and the playful poison-themed naming that inspired creative makeup looks.
What they liked
What they flagged
Nothing. None of the experts who reviewed it raised a problem.
Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.
Independent of what the gurus think, this is what the published research supports about the main active ingredients here.
An eyeshadow palette from Melt Cosmetics featuring poison-themed shade names and a range of colors.
Yes. All 2 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 84%.
Melt Cosmetics Fatally Yours Eyeshadow Palette holds a Guru Score of 84%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 2 expert reviewers we have collected.
Lower-priced eye makeup the gurus still rate highly, versus this mid-range pick.
See how they stack up →Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.
Compare side by side →Stories where our editors dug into this product or its brand.
Spotted something on this page that doesn't look right? Let us know.
A weekly read of the takes worth catching up on: the raves, the splits, the ones the gurus won't shut up about. Free, no spam, unsubscribe whenever.
Subscribe to the digest