James Welsh has put a lot of sensitive skin products to the test, more than 110 of them. He approved most, gave a small share a mixed take, and skipped about one in six, for an approval rate of 71%. His record is generous, and a clear priority runs through it: he rewards barrier-repair ingredients and skips formulas that introduce irritants.
What does James Welsh recommend for sensitive skin?
Across his approvals, ceramides, glycerin, centella, and panthenol keep coming up. These are the ingredients that hold the skin barrier together, and he rates them highly whether they appear in a cleanser, a toner, or a cream. He has a particular warmth for non-stripping cleansers, the kind that clean without washing away the protective layer your skin needs. He called Krave Beauty Matcha Hemp Hydrating Cleanser one of his most staple products ever, and he also praised the Dr. Ceuracle Vegan Kombucha Tea Essence for being moisturizing without feeling heavy, noting that people with oily skin would love it as a moisturizer replacement.
James Welsh's sensitive skin picks, in his words
"Their honey mask is a product that I'm going to love like forever."
"This is probably one of my most staple products ever. As in like, it's always coming back and forth in my routine. It's always a cleanser I fall back on. In fact, when I'm testing new products, it's one of the cleansers I use because I know how well my skin reacts to it. Great for when your skin is stressed out, you want to focus on maintaining the skin barrier. Matcha for antioxidants. We've got hemp seed oil in here as well."
"This is just one of the nicest most hydrating cleansers I've ever used and I don't usually team the term hydrating with a cleanser but when there's 50% glycerin in a cleanser it's obviously going to be hydrating. It's such nice texture. There's aloe, there's oat extract, arginine as well so all soothing and helping to support the skin barrier. You get your money's worth with this cleanser."
"I don't care what anyone says or what your opinion is on Hailey Bieber as a person. This is good. This is a proper occlusive style balm moisturizer, kind of their version of the La Roche-Posay Cica Plast, but [...] in a much more cosmetically elegant way. It has a hyaluronic acid complex and polyglutamic acid which is [...] so nicely hydrating, murumuru butter, and ceramides for barrier support. It's designed to seal everything in overnight and it's really not that heavy as it sounds."
"The Centella and Green Tea Hydrating Gel Cleanser has been one of my favorite cleansers since it launched. It's just that really soothing everyday cleanser that I happily used twice a day. Centella and Green Tea just doing what they do best, antioxidants, soothing, calming visible redness, supporting the skin. And then you got that really high level of glycerin, which [...] keeps you so hydrated whilst you cleanse. It's such a good cleanser."
"I really had to go back into the archives for this one. [...] I used this years ago, but it is making a bit of a comeback. I used this toner non-stop for about two years and my skin was well balanced, there was no excessive sebum production whatsoever, more even skin tone, really probably just down to me consistently using one product consistently. But also the niacinamide in here, I know a lot of people find niacinamide overwhelming because it's in everything, but my skin loves it."
How many products has James Welsh reviewed for sensitive skin?
James Welsh has reviewed 109 products for sensitive skin, for an approval rate of 71%. 77 approved, 13 mixed, and 19 skipped.
What has James Welsh skipped for sensitive skin?
Many of his skips come down to irritation in formulas that are supposed to soothe or heal. In the Murad Cellular Hydration Barrier Repair Cream, he found limonene and linalool, two fragrant irritants, and said plainly that fragrance does not belong in skin-healing products. The product also failed to deliver on its barrier-repair claims. He skipped the Anua Heartleaf 77% Soothing Toner for a similar reason. It stung his face, many of his viewers reported the same, and he felt a toner aimed at irritated skin should not cause more irritation.
"It didn't do that, it didn't even heal my barrier in a month. It contains peptides and Salix alba extract which I'd usually enjoy, but it also contains limonene and linalool, two fragrant ingredients known to be irritants, and I don't think fragrance [...] belongs in skin healing and repairing products. What's even weirder is it doesn't even have a nice smell, it just smells like off tea. This is the worst barrier healing product in my opinion."
"I shared this for a soothing toner and I found this actually stung a lot and a lot of people agreed with me and had the same issue. I cannot stand the heartleaf 77% toner, it's a soothing toner that's stung my face like crazy, it's also too watery when I use it, I lose half the product down my arms. For a product for irritated skin it shouldn't irritate my irritated skin."
"Like it's a mineral sunscreen, not invisible as promoted. And when creators were showing you exactly how sunscreen looks when you apply the recommended amount, the appropriate amount of sunscreen, the amount you should use in order for your sunscreen to be effective, not a dab, not a tiny dot like the Tower 28 promo shows, a full actual application, it just did not blend in. It wasn't invisible at all. Which makes you wonder, did they even test it on deeper skin tones and black skin?"
"It hates one of these UV filters. I'm not sure which one. This isn't an Inkey List thing, it's a chemical sunscreen thing for me. But if you want a sunscreen that's not going to dry your skin down, doesn't smell alcohol heavy, doesn't sting your eyes, doesn't sting your skin, and you don't have rosacea, I would give this one a try. It's a really nice sunscreen, it just feels like a nice quenching moisturizer. Unfortunately my rosacea was not having it."
What should you take from James Welsh's picks?
James Welsh is a generous but principled guide for sensitive skin. He approves readily when the formula is right, but fragrance in a soothing or barrier-repair product is a skip for him, and that pattern runs through his record. He named several Top Picks in this category, among them Prequel Non-Drying Glycerin Cleanser and Peach Slices Redness Relief Azelaic Acid Serum, and his list is a solid place to start for anyone trying to calm and rebuild their skin.
Watch James Welsh say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- Prequel Non-Drying Glycerin CleanserNamed a winnerWatch at 11:57
- Vichy Mineral 89 Hyaluronic Acid Hydrating SerumNamed a winnerWatch at 9:16
- I'm From Rice TonerNamed a winnerWatch at 8:36
- Prequel Barrier Therapy Skin Protectant CreamNamed a winnerWatch at 10:05
- BYOMA Melting Balm CleanserNamed a winnerWatch at 2:59
- Peach Slices Redness Relief Azelaic Acid SerumNamed a winnerWatch at 35:24
- Glossier Milky Jelly CleanserNamed a winnerWatch at 3:27
- Murad Cellular Hydration Barrier Repair CreamSkipped itWatch at 21:48
- Anua Heartleaf 77% Soothing TonerSkipped itWatch at 1:32
- Tower 28 SunnyDays SPF 30 Tinted Sunscreen FoundationSkipped itWatch at 2:17
- The INKEY List Polyglutamic Acid Dewy Sunscreen SPF 30Skipped itWatch at 16:12
- Colorescience Sunforgettable Total Protection Brush-On Shield SPF 50Skipped itWatch at 10:35
- Purito Centella Green Level Unscented Sun SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 6:03
- Tower 28 SOS Rescue SerumSkipped itWatch at 34:43
- Keep Cool Soothe Bamboo Sun Essence SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 6:41
- Herbivore Botanicals Pink Cloud Moisture CreamSkipped itWatch at 12:12
- Milk Makeup Cooling Water Jelly Ice StickSkipped itWatch at 17:24
- Garnier Micellar Cleansing WaterSkipped itWatch at 18:59
- Purito Dermide Relief Barrier MoisturizerSkipped itWatch at 12:42
- First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair CreamSkipped itWatch at 11:14
- BYOMA Moisturizing Gel CreamSkipped itWatch at 46:49
- The Ordinary Natural Moisturizing Factors + HASkipped itWatch at 9:53
- Fresh Soy Face CleanserSkipped itWatch at 7:23
- Kiehl's Creamy Eye Treatment with AvocadoSkipped itWatch at 7:32
About this expert
See everything James Welsh has reviewed
Expert rankings
Related guides
This guide reflects what James Welsh said across his videos about 109 products for sensitive skin, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products he approved. It is general information, not medical advice.